The Growing Support for Same-Sex Marriage: How Three States Took Action with Ballot Initiatives
In recent years, the battle for same-sex marriage rights in the United States has seen a remarkable shift in public opinion, legal challenges, and political action. While same-sex marriage was legalized nationwide by the U.S. Supreme Court’s landmark decision in Obergefell v. Hodges in 2015, the legal and social struggle for LGBTQ+ rights has continued on various fronts. One of the most significant of these has been the efforts by states to ensure that marriage equality remains protected, even in the face of shifting political landscapes or potential rollbacks by federal courts.
In 2024, three states—Nevada, Michigan, and Pennsylvania—passed ballot initiatives aimed at safeguarding same-sex marriage rights in their state constitutions. These initiatives, driven by both political and social concerns, reflect a growing recognition of the importance of enshrining marriage equality into state law in order to protect it from potential federal reversals.
The Need for Ballot Initiatives same sex marriage
The Obergefell decision was a major victory for LGBTQ+ rights, effectively legalizing same-sex marriage in all 50 states. However, the ruling did not prevent future legal challenges to the decision, nor did it guarantee that states would protect same-sex marriage rights if the legal same sex marriage landscape shifted. There was, and continues to be, concern that future Supreme Court justices might overturn or modify Obergefell, as some of the conservative members of the Court have expressed skepticism about the ruling’s legal foundation.
In light of these uncertainties, many states have taken proactive steps same sex marriage to safeguard marriage equality through state-level constitutional amendments or statutory changes. While some states have already passed such protections, others are using ballot initiatives—direct votes by the public on proposed laws or constitutional amendments—as a way to lock in marriage equality at the state level.
Ballot initiatives are particularly appealing because they allow voters, rather than legislators or courts, to determine the outcome of key issues. This process is especially potent in states where lawmakers might be unwilling to pass legislation protecting same-sex marriage due to political same sex marriage or ideological opposition.
Nevada: A State with a History of LGBTQ+ Rights Advocacy
Nevada has long been a bellwether state for LGBTQ+ rights in the United same sex marriage States. In 2002, it became one of the first states to legalize domestic partnerships, and in 2014, the state saw its same-sex marriage ban struck down in federal court. The 2024 ballot initiative aimed to enshrine marriage equality in the state’s constitution was widely seen as a move to strengthen protections and provide lasting legal certainty.
The initiative was driven by concerns over the growing divide in national politics and the increasing risk that marriage equality could be undermined at the federal level. Nevada’s large and diverse electorate includes a significant portion of voters who support marriage equality, as same sex marriage evidenced by previous elections in which pro-LGBTQ+ candidates and policies received strong support. However, in 2024, the state was faced with a divided political climate, particularly after the appointment of conservative judges to the U.S. Supreme Court.
The initiative was framed as a simple, commonsense measure to ensure that same-sex couples would continue to have the same legal rights and protections as heterosexual same sex marriage couples in Nevada. Proponents of the initiative argued that marriage equality was not just about love but about access to critical legal protections, such as healthcare, inheritance rights, and tax benefits, which were essential for families.
Nevada voters passed the initiative overwhelmingly, solidifying the state’s commitment to equal rights for all couples and affirming its place as one of the nation’s leading states in same sex marriage LGBTQ+ advocacy.
Michigan: Overcoming Historical Setbacks
Michigan’s story is one of both progress and setbacks. In 2004, Michigan passed a constitutional amendment defining marriage as between a man and a woman, making it one of the most conservative states on LGBTQ+ issues at the time. This amendment stood as a significant barrier to same-sex marriage, despite changing national attitudes toward marriage equality.
The passage of the 2024 ballot initiative marked a profound shift in the state’s political landscape. By this time, public opinion in Michigan had dramatically changed. Polls consistently showed that a clear majority of Michiganders supported the right to marry for same-sex couples. Yet, while support for same-sex marriage had become more widespread, there was still resistance in parts of the state, particularly in more rural and conservative areas.
In response to growing calls for marriage equality, activists in Michigan took action. They introduced a ballot initiative that would amend the Michigan state constitution to ensure that same-sex couples could marry and enjoy the same legal benefits as heterosexual couples. The campaign for the initiative was led by LGBTQ+ advocacy groups, local civil rights organizations, and political leaders who recognized the importance of codifying marriage equality into the state’s foundational law.
After a vigorous campaign, the initiative passed with strong support from both urban and suburban areas, though it faced opposition from conservative quarters. Michigan’s approval of the marriage equality ballot measure was hailed as a victory not just for the LGBTQ+ community, but for civil rights more broadly. For many, the passage of this initiative was a symbol of the state’s evolving values on equality and justice.
Table of Contents
