Grace Review — All This Unhappiness Is Starting to Feel Fetishistic
Introduction: A Darkening Tone in Detective Roy Grace’s World
Grace, the popular crime drama based on the novels by Peter James, has become known for its portrayal of a world steeped in grief, loss, and dark secrets. Detective Roy Grace (played by John Simm) has spent much of the show navigating the aftermath of his wife’s mysterious disappearance, while solving gruesome crimes in the coastal city of Brighton. However, as the series progresses, there is a growing sense that the show’s emphasis on emotional trauma and tragedy is beginning to feel increasingly one-dimensional and fetishized.
Table of Contents
In this review, we will explore how the emotional weight of the series, which once provided a compelling backdrop to the crime-solving, now seems to overwhelm the narrative, turning the tragic into a narrative crutch rather than a genuine exploration of human suffering. The line between character development and exploitative storytelling becomes more blurred as the episodes unfold. What once felt like a complex, layered portrayal of a detective’s personal struggles now risks becoming a self-indulgent melodrama. Can the series find a way to balance its dark emotional core with the intricacies of the crime genre, or is it slipping into an abyss of emotional exploitation?
The Rise of Unrelenting Darkness
The Emotional Core of the Show
From the outset, Grace established its emotional core in the tragic disappearance of Roy Grace’s wife, Cleo. This event has been the backbone of Grace’s emotional turmoil, influencing not only his personal life but also his approach to solving crimes. His inability to let go of the past and his ongoing quest to find closure for his wife’s disappearance has provided a deep, emotional throughline throughout the series.
In earlier seasons, this sorrowful narrative was tempered by the thrill of the investigation and the intrigue of the cases Grace worked on. Each new case offered a fresh layer to Roy’s character, presenting him with opportunities to confront his past or dive deeper into his grief. This balancing act of personal anguish and professional determination provided the show with a compelling structure that connected both the emotional and procedural elements of the series.
However, as the show enters its later seasons, it becomes clear that the emotional landscape of Grace has not evolved as much as it should have. The storyline surrounding Cleo’s disappearance has become increasingly repetitive, with Grace’s internal conflict being played out in almost identical ways from episode to episode. Instead of the narrative progression one might expect from a detective learning to move on or find new meaning, we’re instead given an endless loop of grief.
Repetitive Themes of Suffering
Each episode of Grace in recent seasons seems to revolve around an endless cycle of unresolved grief, personal tragedy, and emotional stasis. Grace’s refusal to move on from Cleo’s disappearance has become a crutch rather than a source of meaningful character growth. The emotional stakes, once palpable, now feel exploited, as the show continuously forces Grace to face emotional turmoil that ultimately leads nowhere.
This pattern of revisiting his trauma without allowing him to heal or evolve in any meaningful way feels like the show’s creators are milking Grace’s suffering for shock value rather than offering true character exploration. What began as a nuanced portrayal of grief has increasingly turned into a tired narrative trope, where viewers are invited to watch the protagonist wallow in his sadness as a form of entertainment.
The problem here is not the presence of grief or trauma itself, but rather how the show handles it. When emotional pain is used so relentlessly, it stops feeling authentic and begins to feel like a narrative gimmick, designed purely to elicit a response from the audience rather than provide meaningful storytelling.
A Shift in Focus: The Crime-of-the-Week Formula
Emphasis on Procedural Drama
While Grace has always balanced its crime-solving with emotional depth, in recent episodes, the procedural elements have begun to feel like secondary distractions from the overwhelming focus on the personal lives of the characters. The show’s use of the crime-of-the-week format has taken on a more prominent role, pushing the investigation into the background in favor of emotional plotlines that often feel artificial.
The central murder investigations are compelling enough, but they rarely challenge or evolve the characters. In fact, they often feel like mere plot devices used to justify further emotional turmoil or to fill the runtime. The cases themselves tend to be straightforward, and while the criminals are often interesting, they seem secondary to the show’s true focus: Roy Grace’s unending sorrow.
This shift in focus has started to make the procedural side of the show feel like a box-ticking exercise. The investigation doesn’t push the plot forward as much as it serves as a backdrop for Grace’s personal pain. This lack of balance leaves the audience feeling as though they are watching a series that is only interested in exploring darkness rather than solving crimes.
Lack of Meaningful Character Development
The shift to a more crime-centric formula also impacts the development of supporting characters. In earlier seasons, characters like DS Glenn Branson (Richie Campbell) and Grace’s colleagues felt like real, multi-dimensional individuals who provided a sense of relief from the relentless darkness. They had their own emotional arcs and were allowed to interact with Grace in ways that felt both authentic and engaging.
However, in recent seasons, these characters have become increasingly sidelined. Branson and the others are still present, but their personal growth is barely explored. They exist mainly to serve as foils to Grace, and their development is often put on the back burner in favor of showcasing Grace’s pain. This creates a sense of narrative imbalance, where the show’s emotional focus is so narrowly fixed on Grace that the supporting cast is rendered nearly invisible.
The lack of significant character development for Branson and others suggests a deeper flaw in the series: the over-reliance on Grace’s personal journey has caused the entire ensemble to stagnate, preventing the show from evolving into a richer, more complex narrative.
The Fetishization of Suffering
Exploiting Grief for Drama
One of the most problematic aspects of recent episodes of Grace is the increasingly fetishistic portrayal of grief. The series seems to indulge in suffering for suffering’s sake, amplifying Roy Grace’s torment to a degree that feels almost exploitative. Instead of allowing grief to be a natural part of the character’s journey, it is turned into a recurring motif that dominates every aspect of the show. This focus on emotional suffering without any real progression creates a sense of stagnation that undermines the emotional impact of the story.
When grief is continuously presented as a source of drama, rather than as a human experience that evolves and shifts over time, it begins to lose its emotional resonance. Instead of feeling like an authentic exploration of pain, it becomes a recycled plot device used to generate cheap emotional reactions from the audience.
The show’s refusal to allow Roy Grace to heal or move forward feels like an artificial attempt to maintain dramatic tension, even though it comes at the cost of character growth. In essence, Grace is increasingly relying on its protagonist’s trauma as a crutch, rather than using it as a starting point for deeper exploration of grief, healing, and moving on.
An Emotional Trap
By fixating on Roy Grace’s suffering to such an extent, the show runs the risk of becoming a tragedy-fueled emotional trap. Every case, every episode, becomes less about the investigation itself and more about the lingering sorrow that defines Grace’s character. While grief is a universal experience, the repetitive and unrelenting nature of this narrative approach risks turning it into a form of emotional exploitation rather than a meaningful, heartfelt exploration of loss.
Conclusion: Can Grace Find a Way to Evolve?
In Grace, Series 5, and beyond, the show finds itself at a crossroads. The emotional weight that once gave the show its power has become increasingly monotonous, and the crime-solving elements are struggling to hold their own amidst the overbearing emotional drama. The series has an opportunity to evolve and strike a better balance between crime procedural and character-driven storytelling. But as it stands, the show’s reliance on a fetishized portrayal of grief risks undermining its own narrative power.
Ultimately, Grace needs to allow its characters to grow, heal, and move forward. Roy Grace’s journey, though compelling, should not be reduced to a cycle of endless suffering. If the show continues to exploit grief without offering real emotional progression, it will risk alienating viewers who are craving a more nuanced and evolving portrayal of personal trauma. It’s time for Grace to move beyond its current rut and find a way to evolve both its central character and its storytelling approach. Otherwise, it risks becoming a melodramatic exercise in emotional manipulation rather than a compelling crime drama.
