Table of Contents
10 Anime That Proved First Impressions Wrong
Anime is a diverse medium, and its array of genres and styles often leads to initial impressions that can be misleading. Many series begin with premises or presentations that might not fully capture their depth or quality, only to reveal their true value as the story progresses. Here’s a look at ten anime that defied initial expectations and proved that first impressions can be deceiving.
1. Attack on Titan (Shingeki no Kyojin)
Initial Impression: When Attack on Titan first premiered, it appeared to be a straightforward action series set in a world overrun by giant humanoid creatures. The premise seemed to offer a typical survival story with a focus on thrilling battles and a dark atmosphere.
Reality: As the series progressed, Attack on Titan unveiled a complex narrative filled with intricate political intrigue, deep philosophical questions, and surprising plot twists. The story expanded beyond the initial focus on survival, exploring themes of freedom, human nature, and the cost of war. The show’s evolving plot and rich world-building transformed it from a simple action series into a thought-provoking and emotionally impactful experience.
2. My Teen Romantic Comedy SNAFU (Oregairu)
Initial Impression: My Teen Romantic Comedy SNAFU initially seemed like just another high school romance anime with a cynical protagonist and a standard club setting. The character designs and premise suggested a typical high school slice-of-life series.
Reality: The anime quickly distinguished itself with its sharp, introspective writing and its deconstruction of high school romance tropes. The protagonist, Hachiman Hikigaya, offers a unique perspective on social interactions and personal growth, leading to a series that is as much about self-discovery and interpersonal dynamics as it is about romance. The show’s depth and character development set it apart from other series in the genre.
3. KonoSuba: God’s Blessing on This Wonderful World! (Kono Subarashii Sekai ni Shukufuku wo!)
Initial Impression: At first glance, KonoSuba appeared to be a generic isekai (alternate world) series with a focus on comedic parodies of fantasy tropes. The initial promotional materials and synopsis suggested a light-hearted and perhaps shallow take on the genre.
Reality: KonoSuba surprised many with its clever humor, satirical approach to the isekai genre, and endearing characters. Instead of being a typical fantasy adventure, it embraced its role as a comedy, delivering consistently funny and heartwarming moments. The series’ self-awareness and character dynamics turned it into a beloved fan favorite.
4. The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya (Suzumiya Haruhi no Yuuutsu)
Initial Impression: The initial impression of The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya was that of a standard high school anime with a quirky female lead who had a peculiar obsession with the supernatural. The first episodes might seem like a typical slice-of-life with occasional oddities.
Reality: As the series unfolded, it revealed a unique narrative structure and a complex story involving time travel, parallel worlds, and existential themes. The unconventional storytelling, including episodes aired out of chronological order, contributed to a deeper exploration of character motivations and plot developments. The show’s innovative approach and philosophical undertones elevated it beyond its initial appearance.
5. Steins;Gate
Initial Impression: The early episodes of Steins;Gate might suggest a slow-paced, sci-fi series centered around time travel with a heavy focus on dialogue and character interactions. The initial setup might not seem particularly engaging compared to more action-oriented series.
Reality: Steins;Gate gradually reveals itself to be a masterful blend of science fiction and psychological thriller, with an intricate plot that explores the consequences of time travel and its impact on the characters. The slow build-up allows for rich character development and a deeply engaging narrative that pays off in a profoundly emotional and intellectually stimulating manner.
6. Re:Zero – Starting Life in Another World (Re:Zero kara Hajimeru Isekai Seikatsu)
Initial Impression: Re:Zero appeared to be another standard isekai series where the protagonist is transported to a fantasy world with typical elements of adventure and magic. The premise seemed to follow familiar tropes of the genre.
Reality: The series quickly subverted expectations by incorporating a unique mechanic of “return by death,” where the protagonist, Subaru Natsuki, relives his life after dying. This concept introduced a complex narrative full of psychological and emotional challenges, with Subaru’s repeated failures and struggles adding depth and intensity to the story. The show’s focus on character development and dark themes set it apart from more conventional isekai anime.
7. The Promised Neverland (Yakusoku no Neverland)
Initial Impression: The Promised Neverland began with a seemingly typical story of children living in an orphanage, which might appear to be a heartwarming or straightforward slice-of-life series.
Reality: The series took a dramatic turn as it revealed a dark and sinister plot involving the orphanage’s true nature and the children’s desperate struggle for survival. The shift from a seemingly innocent setting to a high-stakes psychological thriller surprised many viewers, showcasing the series’ ability to blend genres and deliver suspenseful and thought-provoking storytelling.
8. Clannad
Initial Impression: Clannad might initially come across as a typical high school romance anime with a focus on everyday life and relationships. The premise suggests a conventional slice-of-life story centered around romance and personal growth.
Reality: As the series progresses, Clannad delves into deeply emotional and dramatic territory, particularly in its second season, Clannad: After Story. The anime explores themes of family, loss, and resilience with a profound emotional impact. The show’s ability to transition from a light-hearted romance to a deeply moving drama demonstrates its depth and emotional complexity.
9. Madoka Magica (Puella Magi Madoka Magica)
Initial Impression: At first glance, Madoka Magica seemed like a typical magical girl anime with a cute and colorful aesthetic, suggesting a standard magical girl series with heroic themes and adventures.
